The Blog The PhotoBlog The Current Robcam Image My Ever-Expanding Music Collection My Bookshelf NOT YET READY The basic info about me which you might need. She hates her job, but she won't leave. Instead she'll moan. Genius. Possibly crazy, but thankfully as inept financially as myself. My favourite blogging student lesbian. Not that there are loads. Just another student, raking his way through the daily pile of crap. Life in Canada. It's scarily poignant at times. Not preaching, more informing. With laughs, beer and tall tales. London's resident party animal and freebie fanatic. Can you feel the sleaziness? Yet another one of us blogging student types. Except he's funny. Sort of... Glorious b+w white photos of London and other places. Simply the most passionate blogger around. His days must be full to bursting with things to do just to put on the blog. A Scottish mother who loves the pipes. Read into that what you will. A great little blog by an American college girl. She even plays a British sport... Yet another of us blogging students. Yes, we really are that lazy. A Swedish (I think) guy who includes me in his 'Blogs As Literature' section. i.e. possibly mad. A London blogger who is fascinated by the overall concept of blogging. He's written a few papers on the subject too. One if the most dedicated blogs, a Londoner who gets up to fifty times as much stuff as I ever do. A British media student / graduate who loves his music. And his boozing. A disgruntled teacher, buried somewhere in Europe. A Canadian mother who seems to like my blog. The so-called Expert Analysis of this very blog, as spoofed by one of my ex-housemates. An American girl who has a thing for British guys. Fair play. An Aussie guy who used to be on a messageboard I was on a while back. The single greatest source of news the web has ever seen. And it's British! My source of Arsenal-related news and gossip. Also has fantastic forums. Where I get my mp3s. Oh-so-cheap and oh-so-easy to use. Fairness & Accuracy In Reporting. A US-based media watchdog. Where I get all of my torrenty goodness. Good forums for newbies too. Gathers together hundreds of news sources from across the web, and is the best place for instant news. An English political and media commentary site, with some brilliant articles on all manner of topics. Groups together all of the left-leaning opinion and editorial pieces from English-language newspapers across the world. Previous Blog List All Blogs A Random Blog Next Blog

Wednesday, October 22

The Handmaidís Tale

Iíve just finished re-reading The Handmaidís Tale by Margaret Atwood. I studied this novel for my English Literature A-Level (cough, A grade, cough) a few years ago, and itís been sat on my shelf ever since. I finally got round to picking it up again, and Iíve been reading it all this week, on the Tube to and from uni each day.

Firstly, I just want to say that it is still an amazing book to read. I must have read it at least 5 times over whilst I was studying it, and bits of it still enthral me with the language and subtle themes running throughout. Flowers are a constant theme, but you donít realise this until near the end when the narrator makes a point specifically about flowers. Thereís a whole host of other themes, but I donít want to list them here for fear of spoiling the novel for any virgin readers.

Saying that, there is a major aspect that Iíd like to pass comment on and explore, during which I will probably reveal a whole bundle of stuff about the plot and characters, so if you havenít read the novel, donít read on. Honestly, donít spoil it for yourself!

CONTAINS SPOILERS...
I remember reading at some point in the past 6 months another blog (Mewing.net, I believe), run by a young woman, where the author had recently read The Handmaidís Tale for the first time. She commented that the book was one of the most feminist and anti-male novels that she had ever read.

I beg wholeheartedly to differ.

I just canít see how this novel can be read as a feminist novel, empowering women and all of that crap. There doesnít seem to be any basis for this hypothesis. The women are treated terribly, whether it be as servants to the men, or as empty shells in which offspring are created and born from. Women are not allowed to work, to have money, to own property, to choose their husbands, to be educated, to be sexually liberated, or even to have friends. They are the lower of the two genders, by far.

Women are no longer whole. Their purposes are divided up within the households. Each man has one or 2 cooks / servant-types, a woman whoís sole purpose is to reproduce, and his ďwifeĒ who is in charge of the household, and is the overall image promoted for it. How can this be a strongly feminist viewpoint?

All of this was in response to the Womenís Lib movement of the 60s and 70s. Women were campaigning to be treated equally, and when this happened, the balance went too far in their favour, forcing the men to rebel and create this new society, in which the power is restored to themselves. As the Commander notes late on in the novel, the men felt as if they were worthless; they had no purpose any more, and even sex had lost its appeal, since it was everywhere: Pornomarts on every corner, ďliberatedĒ women making themselves readily available for sex at every opportunity, and the lack of excitement in the ďhuntĒ for women. Therefore, they rebelled, taking back the power, and reducing women to a lower status than they had before the entire saga.

Even the narratorís hero, Moira, is eventually reduced to serving the men in the regime which she hated so much. She is also forced to have sex with them, and to dress / act as they want her to. For even this feminist icon, with all the power and liberation she represents, to be reduced to this is something that even the most ardent feminist would be hard-pushed to claim was actually empowering to women.

Basically, what I am trying to put across is that whilst The Handmaidís Tale is many things, it is not a feminist book. The Historical Notes section at the end highlights the way in which most of the aspects of Gileadean society exist in todayís society, from the degradation of women in Moslem countries to the monotheocracy in Iran to the use of a secret organisation to force the public to obey the ruling power. All it needs is for these to come together in one culture for there to be a potential Gilead. A scary thought.


0 Comments:

Post a Comment

I power Blogger, with a cool button. TagBoard.com The British Bloggers Directory. ReInvigorate.net Photoblogs.org
View My PhotoBlogs Profile BloggingBrits Home.